Celeste
Thursday, May 15th, 2008Celeste
502 Amsterdam Ave
btwn 84th & 85th St
212-874-4559
**CASH ONLY**
Getting reservations to some restaurants in NYC can be more competitive than a World Series between the Red Sox and the Yankees. There is a sense of triumph when you finally get them, but I find that sometimes there is so much expectation built into the meal that any flaw can disrupt the evening. I prefer to dine without trumped-up expectations, in a restaurant where the food is top-notch and you can relax completely. This is exactly the type of meal I had at Celeste on Saturday night.
I had spent the day walking around on the Upper West Side of Manhattan. For those of you unfamiliar with the city, UWS is an urban environment with all of the benefits of suburbia (ie, trees and quiet). The weather was beautiful, and I was absolutely starving. I was with a friend who happens to be the human equivalent of a Zagat guide, and he automatically led us to Celeste. The restaurant is unassuming on the outside, but is cozy and warm on the inside. They don’t accept reservations so everything is on a strictly walk-in basis. The cuisine is Neopolitan, and the staff all hail from Italy. The owner in particular is ever-present and ensures that each guest is attended to, as though you were in his own home.
The food does not disappoint either. We started off the evening with a glass of prosecco and a sampling of the fresh ciabatta and olive oil that accompanies every meal. Don’t overstuff yourself though—every item on the menu is appealing and you will need as much room in your stomach as possible so you can get a fine sampling of them all. Although the menu is set up in the form of a traditional Italian meal, with antipasti, primi, secondi insalate and dolci courses, you can feel free to mix and match as you choose. Whatever you do, though, make sure you order from the ‘fritti’ selection; this is may be unique to Celeste out of all of the Italian restaurants I have been to (and I lived in Italy for awhile), and everything on it is delectable.
We didn’t stick to the traditional menu, and instead ordered the Insalata Mista and Carciofi Fritti (fried artichoke). The Insalata Mista was a simple salad of fresh mixed greens, dressed with a light balasamic dressing made in-house. It’s a delicious light vegetable course, and helps to balance out one of the many enormous pasta dishes you can order as your main course. The Carciofi Fritti was unlike anything I had ever had before. There is no batter involved here; the artichoke hearts are fried until the edges are crispy and browned and taste a little bit toasted. They are dressed only in the slightest dash of olive oil and a bit of salt; the actual taste of the artichoke is central to the dish. The texture of the crisped edges is a perfect counterpoint to the smooth, soft texture of the inside of the heart. But, the deliciousness doesn’t end there; the center of the plate is filled with a fluffy mound of parsley fried crisp. If you order this dish, make sure you eat the parsley! Not only is it delicious, but the owner stopped by our table and told us how pleased he was that we ate every bite of it. Apparently, many patrons think it is a garnish, but you will make the owner very happy if you devour it with gusto.
For our primary course, my friend and I both ordered pasta. Normally I shy away from pasta when I go out; I often end up eating it at home because it is inexpensive and easy to prepare. At Celeste, the pasta is definitely worth ordering. All of the pasta is freshly made and cooked to al dente perfection. My dish, the Vermicelli alle Vognole (vermicelli with clams), was delicious, garlicky, and sprinkled with fresh parsley. Actual clams in shells, not chopped clams from a can, ring the dish. I ate nearly the entire plate (to be fair, it was a ginormous portion), and was sad to see the last few bites taken away, but my stomach was officially at capacity. My friend felt the same way about his Fettuccine alla Bolognese, a special item on the menu that evening. Again, the pasta was homemade and perfectly cooked. The sauce was loaded with meat, and the precise balance of tangy and sweet that is so difficult to achieve in a good tomato sauce.
Unfortunately, we were too stuffed to order dessert, but the couple next to us raved about the gelato. The tiramisu was also tempting; in a restaurant where everything is so deliciously and authentically Italian, it’s practically guaranteed that the tiramisu will be delicious. I guess I’m just going to have to go back again and try it for myself … and at the oh-so-affordable prices of around $10 an entrée, I can certainly afford to.












